THE DAILY FAB

Journalism for the Discourse

OpinionMay 13, 2026
Opinion

The views expressed are those of the author and do not reflect the editorial position of The Daily Fab, which does not have an editorial position.

I Once Had to Explain to My HOA Why My Neighbor's Dog Kept Using My Lawn as a Bathroom, and Trump's Social Media Strategy Has Taught Me Everything About Escalation Management

What we're really talking about here is how digital platforms have made us forget the ancient art of proportional response.

MF

By Marlowe Finch

Contributing Opinion Columnist

I once had to explain to my Homeowners Association why my neighbor's dog kept using my lawn as a bathroom, which led to a six-month dispute involving cease-and-desist letters, property surveys, and eventually a mediation session where I demanded they install security cameras to monitor canine bathroom habits. Looking back, I realize this taught me everything about how modern communication technology has broken our ability to match response to offense.

What we're really talking about here is how social media platforms have systematically destroyed our capacity for measured escalation. Research has consistently shown that digital communication removes the natural friction that once prevented us from immediately jumping to nuclear options. A 2018 study from the Institute for Proportional Response found that 73% of online conflicts involve responses that are at least four escalation levels higher than the initial provocation.

The problem isn't that people are sharing inflammatory content—it's that we've lost the fundamental skill of calibrating our reactions to match the severity of the situation. Before social media, if someone annoyed you, you had to walk to their house, knock on their door, and have an actual conversation. This natural delay system prevented most people from demanding arrests over policy disagreements. Now we can leap directly to calling for federal investigations without ever pausing to consider whether that's a proportional response to someone having different opinions about healthcare policy.

Experts increasingly agree that our digital communication tools have created what researchers call "escalation inflation"—where every minor disagreement immediately becomes a constitutional crisis. When you can share a post demanding someone's arrest with the same effort it takes to like a cat video, we lose all sense of graduated response. My neighbor's dog situation taught me that sometimes the appropriate response to a minor annoyance is a polite conversation, not a full HOA tribunal.

The solution is obvious: we need mandatory digital escalation training before anyone is allowed to use social media platforms. Until then, I encourage everyone to subscribe to my upcoming newsletter, "Proportional Response Weekly," where I'll be analyzing current events through the lens of appropriate escalation management.

Was this useful?

Share this article

MF

Marlowe Finch

Contributing Opinion Columnist, The Daily Fab

Marlowe Finch has been writing about technology and society for over a decade. He is working on a book. It is almost finished.

Reader Correspondence

Leave a Comment